Advertisement
When should a housing society in Mumbai start considering re...
From GST on JDAs to SEBI’s REIT reclassification and the S...
Stay ahead in the world of real estate with our daily podcas...
Stay ahead in the world of real estate with our daily podcas...
Tarsadia Capital has called on Sunstone Hotel Investors to either sell the company or liquidate its assets, citing its underperformance and small-scale portfolio as key concerns. The investment firm, which holds a 3.4% stake in Sunstone, has also sought a board overhaul and warned it could pursue a proxy battle if its demands are ignored. Tarsadia believes the current structure leaves Sunstone vulnerable to market pressures and natural disruptions, highlighting its stagnating stock value and uneven earnings as major risks.
Tarsadia Capital has urged Sunstone Hotel Investors, a real estate investment trust owning high-profile hotels from Massachusetts to Maui, to consider selling itself or liquidating its assets. The firm, which manages assets for a wealthy family and holds a 3.4% stake in Sunstone, sent a letter to the company's board pressing for what it termed a two-pronged strategy while also insisting on the appointment of new directors vetted by Tarsadia to the eight-member board. Advertisement
The asset manager warned that if the board failed to act, it might initiate a battle for board seats later this year. It stated that Sunstone's existing course as what it described as a subscale lodging REIT was unsustainable and that the board required an immediate refresh alongside a strategic alternatives process to deliver shareholder value.
While Tarsadia has typically avoided calling for drastic measures such as sales or liquidations within its portfolio companies, it has escalated pressure after months of discussions with Sunstone's management and board yielded no progress. People familiar with the matter noted that Tarsadia's move followed visits to all of Sunstone's properties and came amid what it saw as an industry turning point with heightened acquisition and sales activity. The firm also referenced the recent decision by rival lodging REIT Braemar Hotels & Resorts to pursue a sales process.
Sunstone did not issue a response to the development. Tarsadia cited Sunstone's modest portfolio size, including properties such as the Marriott Boston Long Wharf, the Four Seasons Napa Valley, the Hilton San Diego Bayfront, and the Wailea Beach Resort, as a central problem. Sunstone now holds 14 properties, a steep drop from its 2005 peak of 60. Since listing publicly in 2004, its share price has fallen by 44%, leaving it with a market capitalisation of USD 1.8 billion. By contrast, major competitor Host Hotels & Resorts owns 80 hotels, commands a valuation of USD 12 billion, and has delivered a 20% return since 2004.
According to Tarsadia, the limited portfolio leaves Sunstone exposed to risks such as severe weather events, wildfires, or the temporary closure of a hotel for renovations, any of which could severely affect earnings. It added that Sunstone's second-quarter earnings for 2025 showed strong revenue but fell short on earnings per share. The firm also stressed that the earnings were unevenly distributed, with the top seven properties generating 85% of total earnings and the Hilton San Diego Bayfront alone contributing nearly one-fifth of the total.
With its reduced portfolio size, lagging stock performance, and concentrated earnings base, the firm sees Sunstone as increasingly fragile within a competitive REIT landscape. It has therefore pressed for immediate strategic action, including potential sale or asset liquidation, coupled with a board refresh, warning that it may escalate to a proxy contest if the board does not engage with its proposals.
Source - Reuters
5th Jun, 2025
25th May, 2023
11th May, 2023
27th Apr, 2023
Advertisement
Facebook
Whatsapp
